Choice Insurance > Insurance Team

Jay Bartley

Personal Lines Insurance Manager

With Jay, you’ll have a dedicated advisor with many years of experience who is committed to cultivating strong relationships through consistent, quality support catered towards your daily needs.

More About Jay
Jay Bartley headshot

3050 Sienna Drive S
Fargo, ND

O 701.356.9696
D 701.356.3292
C 701.866.0982

Let’s Get Started

Choice Insurance offers a better way to protect your business. With a full line of insurance products and a long list of carriers, we’ll ensure you get the best coverage at the best rate.

Contact Jay Today

Areas of Focus

Personal Lines

Protect what matters most. We’ll customize a coverage plan just for your home, vehicle, lake property and what ever else you need covered.

checkmark icon


Having a quality benefits plan can be key to attracting, retaining, and rewarding employees. Whether you are a sole proprietor or a growing company, we have the expertise to design a plan specifically for your business. No one size fits all here.

Life and Health

Care for your health and provide for your loved ones with life and health insurance. Stop by and let’s review your options.

More About Jay


I started in the Insurance industry in 1997 after finishing my Business Administration degree from North Dakota State University. I love being able to put my 25 years of experience to work for my clients. I enjoy educating my clients and providing them with the best options in the industry. I love working in my home state of North Dakota and managing our amazing team! My career has taken me through several positions in leadership, ownership, and always in sales. I pride myself as being part of this great team. I work closely with my clients throughout the year, helping advise customers of potential risks and providing solutions that protect them from the unexpected. When I am not working with my clients, I enjoy playing golf, following my kids’ golf careers, running, and being at the lake with my two children Layton and Alexis.


From the Choice Insurance Blog


Choice Insurance 2023 Standing Ovation Award

Read More

Insurance, Newsroom

Choice Insurance Named a Most Productive Insurance Agency

Read More

Contact Jay